Uncategorized


As part of my “weird crap my students say” series, these are just from teaching in South Korea. They needed a category of their own.

July 29, 2012

Asked my class where all the boys are. The tiniest, cutest girl says, “Oh teacha, I kill them. All of them.” Then gave a big smile.

I can only cry 3 times in my life: When I’m born, when my parents die, and when the world is destroyed.

July 16, 2012

(As I’m walking home from school) “Jared-uh!!! You are American Idol. Forever!”

June 18, 2012

One student said this in class learning about Father’s Day: “My dad is fat but then he went on diet and now he is very hard.”

June 12, 2012

Had my students create dialogues out of vague situations and then perform 2 minute plays. Here is the best whole class example.

Situation: Going to the bathroom.

(They got to pick 4 random people) They chose: Obama, Lee Myung-bak (President of S. Korea), Jared Teacher, Kim Jong Un.

Kim Jong Un: Hello!
Lee Myung-bak: What are you doing?
Kim Jong Un: I went poo poo.
Jared Teacher: Wow!!
Obama: Good job!

End scene.

 

June 4, 2012

When having the students explain why a skunk could kill a chimpanzee (for an animal wars tournament), one student said the skunk could win, “because it smells like Jared.” Then I taught them about deodorant and realized they had never heard of it. So now I say they smell bad.

May 23, 2012

The dress attire for teachers at my school is so weird. Some are wearing suits, some polos, some dresses, and there’s a teacher wearing a shirt with a cat with a princess crown on it.

May 15, 2012

On my way to class, I told my co-teacher that this particular one was probably my least favorite because they never speak. We get to class and after a couple minutes of them not answering any of my questions, he TELLS them in Korean our entire conversation!

May 14, 2012

To relate to Mother’s Day, I had my students come up with different ways they help their mothers. Last class said, in unison, they they help there mothers by plucking out all of their grey hairs. “It’s Korean tradition.”

April 24, 2012

Here’s part of a letter a student of mine wrote. ” You look very handsome. I think you look like hamesome King Kong. Teacher is good at speak English.”

This was supposed to be a letter about which country they would like to visit.

April 23, 2012

On my way out of school; a boy yelled out of the 3rd floor window, “Teacher teacher! Kiss meeeeeeee!!” I yelled, “No!”. Then he got angry and yelled, “Kiss meeeeee!” again. He kept repeating and yelling it until I was out of sight.

April 16, 2012

Things I’ve learned about where my students would like to travel: They want to go to Somalia to see pirates; Canada to eat/drink maple syrup; Greece to meet Zeus; and North Korea to punch Kim Jong Un.

“America is famous for black people”

April 8, 2012

Had my students describe their family. One student says his father looks like Joseph Stalin.

March 30, 2012

Had my Saturday students form a band and write a song. This group called, ‘Coconut’ wrote this gem of a song.

Title: “Oh! Oh! Oh!”

Verse:

Is grandmother there?

Is grand father there? Speak loud!

Say oh! oh?

Jared You oh! say ho! ho! ho!

We are coconut! I’m oh! Robert Hayden

Richard and French Fry don’t cry don’t cry

trash

Chorus:

Grandmother there? Oh! oh!

grandfather there? oh! oh!

Yeah! Oh! oh! oh!

Yeah! Robert Hayden Richard and French Fry

don’t don’t cry we are good friends

March 16, 2012

Came into my last class and said, ‘Hola’. Instantly 4 boys got up and did their own Korean version of the cha-cha dance.

March 13, 2012

Have a girls class where some decided to call themselves Jesus, Bella, and Lady Gaga.

I also have boys named Mr. Ham, Zombei, November Rush, Potato, and 3 or 4 McDonalds

February 12, 2012

had my students choose English names, one boy picked, ‘Parker’ and everyone started laughing. I asked why and they thought he picked the name, ‘fucker’.

Also, I now have girls who decided to call themselves, ‘Virus’, ‘Adidas’, ‘K-Swiss’, and ‘Black Yak’.

January 16, 2012

Had my students make an advertisement for a restaurant. The best one was definitely “K-Popcorn”.

January 12, 2012

Today some teachers took me out to lunch with them. We get to the car and I asked a teacher if students get excited about sitting in the front seat. They said something that resembles yes, and I said that in America we call it, “riding shotgun”. She looked at me scared and said, “OH! Very dangerous!”

December 16, 2011

Alright just witnessed high schoolers break a window, and the biggest kid (and trouble-maker) in school tore off a huge slab of pointed glass. Needless to say I ran downstairs and got everyone I could find to help. Really scary. Now I get to go home early!

December 7, 2011

I’m teaching my kids about American music this week, and the kids wanted to listen to Justin Bieber (an all boys class). I told them it’s weird because in America, “girls like Justin Bieber but boys hate Justin Bieber, in Korea girls love Justin Bieber and boys love Justin Bieber”. Right after I said that a Korean boy yelled, “GAY!!!!”

December 1, 2011

Taught my 2nd grade high schoolers how to give advice. I gave them scenerios and they had to come up with advice. Their advice for everything, no matter what was, “KILL THEM, FIGHT, HIT, or SUICIDE!!”

November 29, 2011

Had my classes create a menu for a made up restaurant. The classes vote on their favorite restaurant. The winner of the last class was, ‘KKK Kebabs’.

November 28, 2011

Asked my principal what he did this weekend. He said that tried out a new golf course. He then proceeded to tell me that trying out a new golf course is like being a geisha or like “sex” for the first time.

November 16, 2011

Last speaking test of the week. Today’s topic was: ‘If you could be another person, who would you be?” In my all-girls class the instant that was written on the board, a girl yelled, “BOY!!!!”

November 13, 2011

The students have speaking tests all week. First class topic: ‘Which country would you like to go to and why, give details’. So far the best (as far as humorous) is:

“I want to go to America, cause there’s lots uhhh sexy lady!”

October 31, 2011

Taught my middle schoolers the food pyramid in English. I then asked them to brainstorm their favorite healthy and unhealthy foods. For the unhealthy foods they included beer, soju (for the Americans who don’t know this is a very popular vodka-like drink), whiskey, and Makgeolli (rice wine). I teach a bunch of 14 year old alcoholics.

October 24, 2011

“Do you uhhh eatuhhh breakfastuhhhh?”
“Yes I do”
“What do you eatuhhh?”
“Usually cereal. Why do you ask?”
“Becausahhhh Koreans, eat breakfastuhhhh” (awkward stare and walks away)

October 17, 2011

Just walked by a Korean kid on the sidewalk. When he saw me he yelled, “SHOW ME THE MONEY!!!!!!!!”

September 29, 2011

I had a class break up into teams and write out their team name and draw a mascot. One team was, “Sexy on the Beachy”. Their mascot was naked women and penis sharks on the beach.

September 27, 2011

I asked my class to vote on what the best super power is. They picked Santa Clause. This is an all-girls class. I then showed them a picture of what Santa looks like, and they were all mortified.

September 23, 2011

A teacher just gave us beer and fried chicken in school.

September 21, 2011

So for my Korean Teacher’s class I was supposed to teach them how to say, “Where is…. It is on…..” but instead we talked about the movie Seven, what the deadly sins are and the different ways of saying the word prostitute, talked about derogatory terms you shouldn’t say to minorities (they wanted to know), talked about propaganda, the the political spectrum, and Kim Jong Il.

Well that didn’t go as planned

September 16, 2011

September 15, 2011

Just went out into the hallway and there’s two kids on their knees against the wall and my co-teacher slapped one in the head.

 

 

 

The point of this post is to show the absurdity of teaching and the hilarity behind it.

This will base off my career so far which started in 2010-2011 (student teaching). From 2011-2012 I taught in South Korea, and since 2012 I have taught in the Dearborn, MI area in both charter and public schools.

No names will be used other than my own. Enjoy!

November 23, 2016

nov-23-2016-no-shave-november

November 2, 2016

One of my AP students randomly asks,

“Are sharks real?”
“Yes, why?”
“You never hear about them so I didn’t think they’re real.”
“You know there’s a shark week right?”
“Yeah, I thought those were just reruns of Jaws movies.”
~blank stare~

Later in class,
“Are reindeer real?”

October 24, 2016

maynard-sensei-oct-24-2016

One of my former students drew this. Since I taught in Korea someone made an anime picture of me titled “Maynard Sensei”. Since then I get a lot of stuff like this (even though I did karate in 4th grade only).

 

October 24, 2016

Today in my government class learning about judiciary review:

“Whoa, man, are Jews in charge of the Judicial branch too? Like, Jew-dicial. Man they run everything!”

September 29, 2016

A student decided that my spirit animal is a “Jumbo Shrimp”. It has taken off from there.

September 20, 2016

An interpretation of what happened during Bacon’s Rebellion.

April 27, 2016

A student trying to get tips for the AP U.S. History final

March 23, 2016

March 2, 2016

 

February 24, 2016

Student 1: I have a stigmatism in my eye.
Student 2: I don’t get how black people know things. Like how can they figure out where things are, and how do they know what tables are and stuff?
~everyone stares as I look at him mortified~
Me: what are you talking about?
Student 2: Why’s everybody looking at me? I don’t get how they get around and, like, know things.
Me: Black people?
Student 2: No, blind people. What did I say?
Class in unison: Black people!

January 15, 2016

That moment when you get after your students for phones going off in class and it turns out it’s your phone and your mom texting you. Thanks for distracting my class mom.

January 12, 2016

Things I learned today about my fellow white men (as told by an after school make up course of non-white students)

-We are mental
-We like to shoot up schools
-We like to shoot little kids
-We think our sisters are attractive
-When we don’t shower we smell like bologna
-We like NASCAR
-We think we own everything
-We always speak in proper grammar and hate people who don’t
-We hate our parents so much we want to shoot them
-We all own guns

Stereotypes, am I right? *facepalm*

January 4, 2016

A Christmas gift

December 18, 2015

Christmas presents! Inspired by Elf.

December 11, 2015

Got this from a kid

December 9, 2015

Had my formal observation today. During it a student stopped and said, “Mr. Maynard, I want to thank you for putting the question on the board and being the best teacher ever.” Then starts coughing and looking at the administrator to make sure she heard it.

November 3, 2015

You tried?

October 16, 2015

I had to break up two boys passionately arguing about Meryl Streep.

September 18, 2015

In  AP US History  we are learning about the Puritans. When reading a document, I asked the kids basically what the Puritans were trying to accomplish. A student then said that the Puritans were “trying to spread their Christian seed across America.” Later in class he finished his assignment early and wanted to draw something. He then made it look the the Puritan boats were sperm going to the egg of America.

June 1, 2015

“Sexism is bad, and bad is good for women” is something I heard today.

May 27, 2015

Classy

May 15, 2015

Here’s one way to answer a question

May 7, 2015

I was just told I look like Bubba from Forrest Gump and a student just did the Macarena.

 

April 25, 2015
Here’s one way to start an essay
April 22, 2015

Found out a student is suspended for 180 days for having a knife out in class.

What was the knife for? Steak. A kid pulled out a steak in class and started eating it.

 

March 6, 2015

French Revolution project

January 20, 2015

When you teach in an old Spanish room

October 24, 2014

My students were filling out a map of Latin America and Asia to prepare for learning the Spanish American War. They had trouble finding Panama so I told them it’s a Van Halen song. Then a student goes, “Yeah, isn’t that the girl who couldn’t see or talk?” So I guess Van Halen is Helen Keller?

September 19, 2014

A random kid walked in my room and started dancing while repeating, “sausages” over and over.

September 15, 2014

Teaching 6th grade is different than the 9th graders I teach. For example, today a 6th grader pulled out a tooth, set it down, then finished his quiz. It was hardcore.

September 3, 2014

Something nice

May 29, 2014

While simulating the Cuban Missile Crisis, the student playing John F. Kennedy asked if he could, “simulate being with Marilyn Monroe instead.”

May 27, 2014

Learning about the arms/space race today. A student asked (in all seriousness), “You know how the astronauts walked on the moon? How come we can’t do that here on Earth?”

 
April 14, 2014
Student tip of the day: The best way to fall asleep within 30 seconds is to flex every muscle in your body at once. “You’ll pass out quick”.
April 3, 2014
“Didn’t Hitler discover the human body?” was something asked in my class today.
March 11, 2014
A couple weeks ago I had my students simulate the stock market crash of 1929 by buying and selling fake stocks with fake money in class. One student took that skill and invested in a real stock and is going to sell it for a profit of over $600.
February 24, 2014
Only at my school can you say that you’re going on your honeymoon in Jamaica and a kid will say, “Why Jamaica? Iraq is so much better!”
February 14, 2014
Back around October my students had a poster project and I put good ones on the wall. One student asked if he could keep all of them. I said, “Not right now (gives weird look). Why?” He said that he wanted to make a sword. When I took them down he took them home. Yesterday, he gives me something wrapped in a cloth. It is a full working sword made out of the posters, wrapped in tin foil. It is now called, “The Student Slayer”.
December 19, 2013
This was an assignment for why America joined WWI
December 18, 2013
A student gave me a present so I left the box on my desk. Midway through a student said “Mr. Maynard, I touched your box so now a part of me is always inside you.”
November 14, 2013
Come at me bro!
November 10, 2013
Here’s one way to suck up

 

Hello everyone (anyone?)

I just randomly logged in and saw that I have used this type of blogging system for college classes-more specifically something to do with English/Language Arts education. I’ve been thinking about starting a blog for a few months now and have some time to do it. It’s weird looking back 6-7 years ago to see what I used to write and the assignments I used to do. Good times. This post is to explain why I am writing and what I will most likely be writing about…..

As a 29 year old (old!) married man who may have a family soon, I came to the realization that I need to write. I do not qualify myself as a good writer. In fact I get very nervous at the thought of writing. However, there’s so much stuff in my brain I have to let loose.

To give some background, I am a social studies teacher in Dearborn, MI. I absolutely love my job-no matter how crazy it gets. With the new presidential administration and the growing problems public schools I am very nervous for the future.

With that in mind these are some goals I have for writing:

-First I am going to post all the funny things that happened to me as a teacher. The point is to show the absurdities of the profession. Other than mine, no names will be used to protect the innocent.

-I have been trying to write about the current state of affairs creatively. My source is the punk rock band NOFX’s 1999 song, “The Decline”. Lyrically it is probably my favorite song of all time. Every since around 2011, when I went to South Korea to teach, I have planned in my head a story based off the lyrics of the song. I have not written a single word yet. So some blog posts may be lyrics from that song with me trying to be creative with it.

-Write about the state of affairs of the United States, the world, and my life in general. The basis is to get it out there and fully flesh out thoughts I have about what is going on.

-Write about what I know. I have a myriad of interests: my wife, travel, music, sports, teaching, history, comedy, reading, craft beer, philosophy, financial fraud, politics, school, etc. Basically whatever is on my mind I want to write about it.

So here we go!

“What is this thing?” asked George.

“I’m not really sure; it looks so ancient and breakable. Nothing looks like it will change on it unless you write on it,” explained Lucy.

Things have been different since the oil was completely drained on Earth. For three hundred years the Earth was able to supply us with everything we needed.

“It’s so fragile and worn out. I don’t know where I’m even supposed to put it,” said Lucy confused.

“I think you can take it anywhere you want like a computer, but it’s a lot tinier. What if you lose track of it and lose it, are there more of them?” asked George.

“Most of them were located on the internet, and the rest of the copies were recycled to make more computers I think,” answered Lucy.

It’s hard to think about how all of these ancient peoples used to do things. First they had to find something to write on and then they had to find some sort of stick to scratch it down. It seems like something cavemen would do. Where would they get the ink supply to put at the end of the stick things? I can see why ink’s supply became extinct because people kept scratching and scratching. Who could even understand what they were trying to display? There was no font to choose from and no grammar rules to look at. These people must have been really dedicated and smart.

“I can understand the words but it reads funny,” said Lucy.

“What do you mean?” asked George.

“You have to read it horizontally; you can’t just keep looking down and down to get to the end. You have to keep flipping to the next stage of writing,” explained Lucy.

“That is really weird, are there pictures and graphs or anything else that’s visual?” asked George.

“Nothing, it’s as if you have to imagine all of this on your own,” explained Lucy.

Since the last drop of oil was used everything went black. People felt as if they had traveled back through time to the 1800s or further. Centuries ago they heard that people had to live this way but they had no idea. When the blackout happened there was no use for much of anything anymore. Computers had to be thrown away; phones could not be used for anything, transportation was obsolete. Bicycles were pretty much the only form of transportation people could use.

No one knew what to do anymore. People had to start actually talking to other people in person. People had to wait to talk to people, and people couldn’t have anything instant anymore. No more instant popcorn, instant messaging, instant tickets to concerts, nothing was instant anymore and people had to wait. No one could listen to music anymore and most of the corporations on the planet failed. Everyone was on the streets facing something they never really had to do before…each other. No one had any sort of entertainment and no way to cook and prepare food. People treated each other as if they were animals.

“I can’t read the rest of this, there’s too much dirt on it,” Lucy complained.

“Let’s keep digging around and see if we can find more of those things,” suggested George.

The two kept digging around for more of what used to be called books. They searched under broken computers and broken roads where civilization used to be.

Questions for “The Hitman”

  1. What is this character’s favorite kind of music?
  1. What is this character’s calling in life?
  1. What is this character’s major goal in life?
  1. Would this character like sports, and which one(s) would they like?
  1. Where does this character shop for clothing?
  1. What would this character wear out in public?
  1. What does this character look like from the neck down?
  1. What does this character look like from the neck up?
  1. What would this character keep in the car for a long drive?
  1. If the character watches TV, what would be their favorite show?
  1. What was the last thing that made the character cry?
  1. Does the character have pets? If no, why not? If yes, what kind?
  1. What is on the character’s dresser?
  1. How would the character complete this sentence: “I would never…”?
  1. How would the character complete this sentence: “To live a full life one must…”?
  1. What was the last thing this character said to his mother?
  1. What is this character’s biggest fear?
  1. Who is this character’s hero?
  1. What does this character enjoy the most?
  1. What is the last thing that made this character cry?
  1. What was the last thing to make this character laugh?
  1. What does this character like to do with their free time?
  1. What do you think this character’s biggest regret is?
  1. If this character was on a desert island, what 3 things (besides food, water, and shelter) would this character bring?
  1. What is this character’s favorite food?

Rubric

After reading, “The Hit Man”, think about the main character not in just terms of what happened in the story, but who this character is. Think about, based off the story, what the main character would be in to, their passions, the things that make them tick. Try to answer all the questions and use the question guide and answer the questions as detailed as you can. After each question is answered write a character sketch. A character sketch highlights several important characteristics or personality traits of a person. This will help you know the character as if they were a real person and not just a character in a story.

An important aspect of this writing assignment is to not just provide a summary, or even just list the answers you wrote on the answer sheet. The point is to provide a sketch for what this character is. When someone reads this paper they should feel as though they know who the character is before they read the story. For starters to help out, you can first write about someone you know as an example. You could fill out the questions about that person and then think about how you would describe them in a sketch-like format.

I want you to read the story, and then re-read it as many times as you need to pick out all the essential parts of the character so you feel as though you know them.

It may be challenging to take single and seemingly unrelated sentences to make a sketch but think of it as describing one of your friends. Use transition sentences that make the paper flow from one topic to the next. Employ sentence variety too, not every sentence should start with, “This person’s favorite thing is… or They like to do this….”. Use clear and concise sentences and use relevant evidence from the text to answer your questionnaire. For instance, put in an example of why you put down your answer for the question.

Each character sketch will be graded on the following:

On track! Getting There… Needs more attention… At least try!
Questionnaire completion At least 15 questions answered 10 questions answered 5 questions answered Less than 5 answered
Effective use of transitions Feels as though someone just didn’t copy their answers into written form. Reads like they are getting to know someone. Close to the on track but there are few instances of sentences that don’t connect. Reads as a list with little attempt to transition Is just like a list
Cohesiveness and structure Flows easily and is well organized Flows somewhat well an has some degree of organization Scattered, unorganized Didn’t even try to write much at all
Use of relevant details Each detail of the character is carefully distinguished and makes sense There are some details as to why the character is like how they are Not many details, some random explanations No details at all
Grammar Not many grammar mistakes A few mistakes A lot of mistakes I can’t read it
Length At least a page long Not enough details to make a half page but there’s some there Not much at all Nothing

I envisioned having students start this around the very start of their high school lives, probably in the first week or two of the class. This story can be used in a bullying sense and give appreciation to other characters and how they are influenced by their surroundings. In model 9.1 there is an emphasis on how to approach reading a short story. I chose The Hitman because it is very short and it is a story with headings on top of each paragraph or two highlighting the stage of life the character is in. It can be a relatively easy introduction to this topic, while at the same time giving them some ideas to think about within the text involving bullying, individuality, morality, and characterization.

As a reader I want my students to make connections to themselves. I want them to see what this character finds valuable in their life and how he got to that point. The character sketch is supposed to have them dig deeper and put the character in relatable terms. Terms that many people share but may not be highlighted in the text. I want the readers to see the progression of this man and how the headings enhance the story. In the process they should analyze the character and how the plot, setting, conflicts, and any other aspect influence the character. Everything in this story is in there for a reason and it chronicles someone from their childhood to adulthood. All of these processes emphasize the character.

As a writer I want them to see how the headings fit and see how it fits. I want them to analyze how well this shows this man’s progression through life and if it could work any other way. As a writer for this assignment I want them to dig deeper in the details of what the author has shared with the audience and write about who this character is. They should be able, with the questions to find a relatable stance on what makes this character and why they are the way they are. In the actual character sketch I want them to practice sentence variety and creating transitions. This is important because making something narrative from a questionnaire or bullet points can be an important writing task. The clear and concise sentences are to practice this style of writing for later in their high school career as well as for college.

The biggest thing I want my students to learn fit in the 9th grade expectations in section 9.1. Character development and basically characterization (under Narrative Text) are the keys and along the way they’ll take into consideration the plot, setting, and the conflicts in order to fill out this sketch (Under Genre Studies). In the process they have to read to know understand the story and the questionnaire should help them think about and analyze the main character (Under Reading, Listening/viewing strategies and activities). I think this assignment fits into several overarching goals of the 9th grade curriculum. It helps to understand and practice writing as a recursive process. They have to draft a paper and write often which works on fluency (1.1). It definitely helps with using writing for understanding and growth. The whole point of the assignment is to learn and understand the main character of this story (1.2). It also allows the students to communicate in writing using content, form, voice, and style appropriate to the audience and purpose (1.3). The purpose of this assignment is to give an analysis of what this character is like in different situations where if someone read the sketch, then the story would make perfect sense. In the process the students would be gathering and studying evidence from the story to answer the questionnaire (1.4) which helps them draw conclusions and make a sort of report. The overall arching unit is about identity and looking at other people’s identities and finding and realizing the similarities and differences. For model unit 9.1 I think the main purpose is to introduce the students to the standards of good writing and to expose them to stories like The Gift of the Maji, to give them a feel for identity and short story writing.

The students will make one draft, share with a partner and then turn in a final copy the next day (since it is a short assignment).

9.1, Genre studies. Plot, setting, conflict, CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT, mood tone style

Literary Devices: narration/point of view

Reading, Listening/viewing strategies and activities: Read first to understand, then analyze, summarize information,

Narrative Text: examine characterization, self assess

Writing Stratgies: employ sentence variety, use transitions effectively, use clear and concise languages.

Response to Laura Zeichman’s paper.

On track! Getting There… Needs more attention… At least try!
Questionnaire completion At least 15 questions answered 10 questions answered 5 questions answered Less than 5 answered
Effective use of transitions Feels as though someone just didn’t copy their answers into written form. Reads like they are getting to know someone. Close to the on track but there are few instances of sentences that don’t connect. Reads as a list with little attempt to transition Is just like a list
Cohesiveness and structure Flows easily and is well organized Flows somewhat well an has some degree of organization Scattered, unorganized Didn’t even try to write much at all
Use of relevant details Each detail of the character is carefully distinguished and makes sense There are some details as to why the character is like how they are Not many details, some random explanations No details at all
Grammar Not many grammar mistakes A few mistakes A lot of mistakes I can’t read it
Length At least a page long Not enough details to make a half page but there’s some there Not much at all Nothing

Laura- This is an excellent character sketch. You hit on everything I was looking for and added more. You definitely captured the essence of the character and added some great insights such as his child, classical music reference, his meticulousness, and his love of fencing. I love you how really developed this character and added a spin or explanation of how the Hit Man died. It tied together very nicely. Your translation of the questions to the sketch is right on and the specifics and examples are good and relevant. If reading this before reading the story, you will definitely get inside the Hit Man’s head and see who this character really is. Awesome job, you really captured this character.

A.

This is the assignment, rationale (all in a previous blog too) and the rubric with the graded response to Laura Z’s completed assignment.

eng 310 first assignment

Below is Nicole Baniukaitis assignment that I completed

ENG 310 nicole’s assignment

Also here is the story that Laura read for my assignment

The Hit Man

I really enjoyed reading Pitts’ columns. He has the perfect amount of incite, comedy, and sarcasm to get his point across. We all read in class the article about his ways of describing what makes a man. It’s very powerful stuff. My favorite article was about Sarah Palin. I am a liberal minded person especially when compared to the conservative mind so naturally I think Palin is a quack and should have no business even poking her head into politics because I think it’s way over her narrow minded oil drilling head. So when Pitts wrote something about Palin, I had to read.

This whole article could be summed up with these lines:

“Something is wrong when we celebrate mental mediocrity like yours under the misapprehension that competence or, God forbid, intelligence, makes a person one of those “elites” — that’s a curse word now — lacking authenticity, compassion and common sense.”

He touches upon a great point that people are accepting mediocrity. He sort of says that people like the fact that she’s stupid. I mean people are relate-able if they are like themselves. And I have heard that people that do like her think she has the average American in mind. If they like the fact that she’s incompetent and no one knows what she’s talking about then lets have her run the country. I mean we already put up with 8 years of Dubya, and that turned out great. If people really want one of their “own”  to run the country and Palin runs for presidency and wins then America is in deep trouble because that means us English teachers will have to teach extra hard to give some common sense to the majority of our country.

Jared Maynard

Rubric

In this New York Times article, Donadio brings up some interesting points of criticism of Ellie Weisels’s Night. Night is a very popular novel, and one that we have done extensive analysis on, but it does not hide from critical reviews. Critical analysis of a text is always a good thing and something we strive for in this class. It helps to think about the text in different and critical ways. It helps to see the validity in a document and question what it is really telling in a situation. The Holocaust is a topic that more and more people are trying to figure out. It was a horrible event that is hard to comprehend people being a part of. Night does give a great first person narrative of a real-life but does it give us the whole story? Do certain parts of the story try to convey a meaning that deters away from the main point? Are there other parts of the story that promote other meanings that are potentially bad? Or are is this story just not very good or telling? These are some of the questions critics try to answer or critique. Critiques are also important because criticism open’s the public eye to new books. People naturally want to know what is controversial. It can raise public intellect because it gives readers new ways of looking at novels and have them question why certain things are the way they are in a novel. It can also make literature better in the future because if something is not true or not all the way true, authors will do more research and think about criticism before they even start and make the novel richer.

Your task is to either write about the different critiques Donadio talks about in his article or to make a critique of your own. Either way you must create or defend an argument and back it up with relevant details. The point is to inform people of a different perspective that an average person may not exactly catch after one read. If the argument is not backed up with relevant details to support your argument then it probably won’t make much sense and the reader will dismiss it. 2-3 pages should be enough length to get your thoughts out.

Today is Friday and you will have until Monday to turn in a rough draft and will have until next Friday to turn in a final copy. On Monday you will workshop your rough drafts with other students, and then have the rest of the week to finish.

Topics:

  • Does Night fail to create a coherent artistic world out of one which was the deliberate negation of all values?
  • Does Weisel simply just “pour salt” on the Jewish wounds and not let them heal?
  • Does Weisel promote “peace and human dignity” with this novel? (What he won the Nobel Prize for)
  • Is Weisel too “universal” with his writing? Should he include more details about what happened?
  • Do you think Weisel is just looking for press and wrote the story for publicity?
  • Or write about something else you found odd or in need of criticism.

Your papers will be graded on:

A B C D
Thesis/Argument The argument is grounded with sufficient details and makes sense There are some good details to back up a relatively good argument The argument is not supported with good details The argument makes no sense
Paragraph Structure Each paragraph details a specific example of the argument and explains it clearly Each paragraph details an example of the argument and Paragraphs are fuzzy and seem to just be thrown in there No structure at all
Cohesiveness Flows easily and is well organized Flows somewhat well an has some degree of organization Scattered, unorganized Didn’t even try to write much at all
Grammar Less than 1 or 2 grammar mistakes Less than 1 or 2 grammar mistakes but a couple spelling errors Enough grammar errors to distract the reader Too many grammar errors

This assignment will be done somewhat towards the end of the year in an 11th grade classroom. It is part of Unit 11.5 which is called, “The DNA of Survival”. As a reader I want them to learn about the depths of human tragedy and how people survive horrific events. I want them to read and find out what sacrifices of everyday life people have to give up. I want them to learn how to be open-minded when reading and apply the experiences to their lives.

As writers I want them to pay attention to specific events and analyze them. The point of this writing assignment is to think of the story and what makes it work and what does not make it work. This essay is to make them pick apart the novel and to create, come up with, argue against, or argue for an argument.

For the GLECS it fits under Unit 11.5 under Literacy Criticism. It involves critical reading of the text to find aspects to argue for. It also makes the students write a persuasive essay finding supporting evidence to back up the argument.

In the broad sense of the curriculum, this will be the final assignment before reading Maus. It will give them experience of looking at critiques of texts and experience in persuasive essays and critiques. After reading Maus they will do a comparative essay of the two survival novels.

After reading, “The Hit Man”, think about the main character not in just terms of what happened in the story, but who this character is. Think about, based off the story, what the main character would be in to, their passions, the things that make them tick. Try to answer all the questions and use the question guide and answer the questions as detailed as you can. After each question is answered write a character sketch. A character sketch highlights several important characteristics or personality traits of a person. This will help you know the character as if they were a real person and not just a character in a story.

An important aspect of this writing assignment is to not just provide a summary, or even just list the answers you wrote on the answer sheet. The point is to provide a sketch for what this character is. When someone reads this paper they should feel as though they know who the character is before they read the story. For starters to help out, you can first write about someone you know as an example. You could fill out the questions about that person and then think about how you would describe them in a sketch-like format.

I want you to read the story, and then re-read it as many times as you need to pick out all the essential parts of the character so you feel as though you know them.

It may be challenging to take single and seemingly unrelated sentences to make a sketch but think of it as describing one of your friends. Use transition sentences that make the paper flow from one topic to the next. Employ sentence variety too, not every sentence should start with, “This person’s favorite thing is… or They like to do this….”. Use clear and concise sentences and use relevant evidence from the text to answer your questionnaire. For instance, put in an example of why you put down your answer for the question.

Each character sketch will be graded on the following:

On track! Getting There… Needs more attention… At least try!
Questionnaire completion At least 15 questions answered 10 questions answered 5 questions answered Less than 5 answered
Effective use of transitions Feels as though someone just didn’t copy their answers into written form. Reads like they are getting to know someone. Close to the on track but there are few instances of sentences that don’t connect. Reads as a list with little attempt to transition Is just like a list
Cohesiveness and structure Flows easily and is well organized Flows somewhat well an has some degree of organization Scattered, unorganized Didn’t even try to write much at all
Use of relevant details Each detail of the character is carefully distinguished and makes sense There are some details as to why the character is like how they are Not many details, some random explanations No details at all
Grammar Not many grammar mistakes A few mistakes A lot of mistakes I can’t read it
Length At least a page long Not enough details to make a half page but there’s some there Not much at all Nothing

I envisioned having students start this around the very start of their high school lives, probably in the first week or two of the class. This story can be used in a bullying sense and give appreciation to other characters and how they are influenced by their surroundings. In model 9.1 there is an emphasis on how to approach reading a short story. I chose The Hitman because it is very short and it is a story with headings on top of each paragraph or two highlighting the stage of life the character is in. It can be a relatively easy introduction to this topic, while at the same time giving them some ideas to think about within the text involving bullying, individuality, morality, and characterization.

As a reader I want my students to make connections to themselves. I want them to see what this character finds valuable in their life and how he got to that point. The character sketch is supposed to have them dig deeper and put the character in relatable terms. Terms that many people share but may not be highlighted in the text. I want the readers to see the progression of this man and how the headings enhance the story. In the process they should analyze the character and how the plot, setting, conflicts, and any other aspect influence the character. Everything in this story is in there for a reason and it chronicles someone from their childhood to adulthood. All of these processes emphasize the character.

As a writer I want them to see how the headings fit and see how it fits. I want them to analyze how well this shows this man’s progression through life and if it could work any other way. As a writer for this assignment I want them to dig deeper in the details of what the author has shared with the audience and write about who this character is. They should be able, with the questions to find a relatable stance on what makes this character and why they are the way they are. In the actual character sketch I want them to practice sentence variety and creating transitions. This is important because making something narrative from a questionnaire or bullet points can be an important writing task. The clear and concise sentences are to practice this style of writing for later in their high school career as well as for college.

The biggest thing I want my students to learn fit in the 9th grade expectations in section 9.1. Character development and basically characterization (under Narrative Text) are the keys and along the way they’ll take into consideration the plot, setting, and the conflicts in order to fill out this sketch (Under Genre Studies). In the process they have to read to know understand the story and the questionnaire should help them think about and analyze the main character (Under Reading, Listening/viewing strategies and activities). I think this assignment fits into several overarching goals of the 9th grade curriculum. It helps to understand and practice writing as a recursive process. They have to draft a paper and write often which works on fluency (1.1). It definitely helps with using writing for understanding and growth. The whole point of the assignment is to learn and understand the main character of this story (1.2). It also allows the students to communicate in writing using content, form, voice, and style appropriate to the audience and purpose (1.3). The purpose of this assignment is to give an analysis of what this character is like in different situations where if someone read the sketch, then the story would make perfect sense. In the process the students would be gathering and studying evidence from the story to answer the questionnaire (1.4) which helps them draw conclusions and make a sort of report. The overall arching unit is about identity and looking at other people’s identities and finding and realizing the similarities and differences. For model unit 9.1 I think the main purpose is to introduce the students to the standards of good writing and to expose them to stories like The Gift of the Maji, to give them a feel for identity and short story writing.

The students will make one draft, share with a partner and then turn in a final copy the next day (since it is a short assignment).

These are some of the standards I found, but in a scattered form

9.1, Genre studies. Plot, setting, conflict, CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT, mood tone style

Literary Devices: narration/point of view

Reading, Listening/viewing strategies and activities: Read first to understand, then analyze, summarize information,

Narrative Text: examine characterization, self assess

Writing Stratgies: employ sentence variety, use transitions effectively, use clear and concise languages.

What have we accomplished today? Not much that I can see, well kind of now that I look at it. Still, the whole day was kind of disappointing to me. We did get a couple of things done that I am okay with. We decided to look at standards, do a writing assignment, and spend the last day sharing our writing as a class. Most of this is good. I like sharing what I have written this semester because this is the first time I have really started to write creatively. Most of this is because of my creative writing class and deciding to have an English minor last summer. I liked that I have learned to write creatively, and even write in general something that wasn’t a history or political science paper. It allowed me to be myself, it allowed me to want to think creatively in writing, and through some of the literature I’ve read it has given me some cool ways to show my social studies class the horrors of the Civil War (Shiloh anyone?)

I like the writing assignment that we have decided to do because it kills a couple birds with one stone: it gives us some sort of final assessment for the end of the year (and doesn’t give us a real final exam) and it teaches us how to assess writing ourselves while trying to learn the GLECs. First and foremost those are the things that we need to learn about and have practice in. I really didn’t think we could get by the rest of this semester and not do anything. To me this is a slam-dunk and something that will be very useful to us for the rest of the semester and the beginning of our teaching lives. It seemed to take forever to finally get to that decision but it was made none the less and the language of the first proposal of the same thing was finally cleared up.

The process of figuring out the rest of our semester with the “Roberts Rules” seemed to be a bit chaotic for me. I certainly understand giving people power to second a motion and having people discuss the topic and then do a vote. However, it seemed that a lot of things we talked about, motioned, seconded, and spent a great deal talking about really seemed to distract what was proposed in the first place. In my opinion, instead of randomly yelling out something that we wanted to do, I thought we should have gone down the list of proposals and see how they related and talk about the overall issue. I think a lot more would have been done. Obviously the hot-button topics were learning the standards (along with figuring out how to plan around them and make a yearlong syllabus), learning some assessment strategies, and figuring out what should be due on the last day and what we should do on the last day. It just seemed like someone would bring up some sort of vague request that needed more attention and brought more questioning that wasted time trying to figure out what is right for our semester. Part of me ranting is a little bit of me expressing a fault of mine which is not being able to move fast enough with all the different topics. I tend to think hard about what someone previously said and then when new topics come up I try to completely think and understand that. To me it just seemed that a lot of the tangents took away from the overall picture of trying to figure out what is best for us for the rest of the semester.

For the most part I may be suffering from, “Well no one agrees with my exact syllabus of I came up with and how people should believe what I believe-itus” or some run on sentence I’m trying to come up with to be witty but it’s true. I wanted to look at standards, figure out a writing assignment and do something fun the last day. We got that part somewhat figured out. What we didn’t agree on, for some God-forsaken reason I can’t seem to fathom, is voting down writing questions to teachers and have it videotaped. WHAT THE HELL?!?!?!?!?!?!?! I am completely dumbfounded that a motion like this was so overlooked and called for a vote so fast. The only reason I thought it could be a vote was because it seemed like such an obvious activity for us to exercise and learn from. I for one am going to be student assisting next semester and so are others. How would it not be a good or even great idea to communicate with REAL- LIFE secondary English teachers before we enter the game? It gives us a pretty easy way to talk to teachers about a number of things: GLECs, how they deal with them, strategies they use in the classroom, how they like to plan for classes, how they do lesson plans, how to handle poetry, how to handle any other forms of assessment, their teaching philosophy, the research they do, how they handle parents, what they do with their free time, when is their free time, how long it took to get comfortable with themselves in the classroom, learn about the lifestyle they lead in order to be better teachers, what they do when things go wrong, right, or nothing at all, learning how far in advance they plan classes, how influenced they are by technology, what gets them in trouble with administration and/or parents, what kind of leniency they are allowed in the classroom, what kind of reading schedule do they have outside the classroom, see if they have a life at all, figure out the little things to do right in the classroom….. basically we could ask secondary  teachers ANYTHING we wanted to help us in the future and have it all on tape (by Dr. Ellis’ own suggestion which is fantastic she has that ability) and over half the class says no. I think it’s absolutely ludicrous this opportunity could be lost, and wish I knew of a way after the vote to say something about it. That is why I left with an uneasiness in my stomach and don’t feel as though things went right and I believe we need more time to discuss what needs to be done. Most congressional roundtable talks don’t last just 45 minutes (I know as a class that’s all we have and this is my idealistic rant) but that’s my opinion. I feel we lost a great opportunity to tap into teacher’s knowledge of what they are doing in a secondary classroom today.

Next Page »